Board Thread:Community Decisions/@comment-33255378-20180111111910/@comment-32334892-20180111234137

RemosPendragon wrote:

Sure. Chapter being from a second Founding does not neccessarily make it non-canon-friendly... but it likely does so anyway. Because 2nd Founding chapters are always so badass, so cool, so edgy, so powerful et cetera. They are also likely to be legion-builders... and from traitor gene-seed.
 * 2nd Founding

Plus I have seen official sources for 2nd Founding chapters in Chapter Approved booklets, codices and other publications too... to me they look pretty solid lists. Even that Apocrypha of Skaros which fails to name all of the 23 Ultramarines primogenitors seem solid.. i I mean, if there are 24 Ultramarines primogenitors, 12 of them are already named, all fanon chapters that would interact with more than 12 of those chapters would automatically be NCF.

Though main reason is that 2nd Founding chapters are always overpowered Mary Sue shitbags that I do not wish to see on this site and I hope none of the other users do so either. how would a single article interact with 12 chapters and they just so happen to be Ultramarines Successors?

Second there is no complete list for 2nd Founding Chapters.

and who says they have to be cool and NCF

personaly i'd like to make a 2nd founding Chapter that died during the War of the Beast.