User blog comment:Abyssal Horror/Horus Heresy AT/@comment-9465750-20120720085204/@comment-3258762-20120720180611

Not sure if i fully agree with you there, DoW.

Abaddon is tactically much better than any chapter master, i will give him that, but in combat thats another matter. He could probably beat many chapter masters, but i think those like Grimnar, Tu'Shan, Asterion Moloc and Cervan Dante could stand a chance and even beat him (Although i would say that for all of them its a 50/50 battle with no way of saying Abaddon wins here or vice versa)

But he's still not as big a tactical genius as Creed or Macharius.

That got me thinking: Who's greatest

Ursakar E. Creed vs Solar Macharius in BEST GENERAL!