User blog comment:Supahbadmarine/Too Many Loyalists!/@comment-1745925-20110602230602/@comment-2253300-20110604140800

Well if I had my way the Survivors and the Brotherhood of the Faithful would originally have been the same group of Loyalists. After the dust had settled the Marines that would make up the Survivors decide to go into exile, believing that the Imperium would never forgive them for being parts of Legions that had betrayed. The other would go back to the Imperium and form the Brotherhood. The Original Marines of the Brotherhood would surrender some of their pure Gene-seed. Regardless of the infamy of the Gene-seed's origin it would be too precious to give up. These would be used to create further Chapters, though they would always be sure to mix them with the Gene-seed of the Loyal Chapters in hopes that it would inspire loyalty. That is the idea in a nutshell. I think it is a good idea, but it would require a lot of collaboration from the Users involved. Furthermore all of the non-Brotherhood Chapter would not be aloud to be 3rd founding.