User blog comment:Vivaporius/One Year Later: The Xai'athi/@comment-10514705-20120212102742

Well, first of all, congrats on being a member here for a full year. :)

Right, down to business. I have been a long time advocate for the Xai'athi, and along with Supah, I have given you a lot of advice over the past year and you have made many concessions. I can understand why you do not have the same enthusiasm for the project, seeing as it has morphed considerably and that the community has taken a more adversarial stance as of late. However, they have come to fit the Canon more snuggly over this time, and they are generally well liked. So, I would advocate option 1.

As for your work as a whole, I must say that it is very original, and you have brought several very imaginative concepts to the 40k universe. Excluding the Xai'athi (which has already been discussed) your most noticeably impressive endeavours are the planets of Ulaka and Zelus, and the different idea behind both, as you tie weave them into the Canon (and the setting) seamlessly. I would also like to commend your creation of the Ordo Seructia, which fits the macabre feel of 40k perfectly (hell, I'm still surprised that GW never went down a path towards a similar idea, seeing as it seems obvious).