User blog comment:DirgeOfCerberus111/An Alternate Universe? Let the heresy begin!/@comment-1932673-20110830212500/@comment-1932673-20110831114918

Just to point it out but those ideas could coexist, because if there wasn't a fall, that doesn't mean that Eldar wouldn't have a civil war, after all the craftworld eldar kill each other from time to time. This Eldar Civil war could weaken them sufficiently for the 'Many Empires' theory to come about.